Property

South Orange Village Twp., NJ 07079 120 Milligan Pl

120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 1120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 2120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 3
24 more
120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 4120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 5120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 6120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 7120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 8120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 9120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 10120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 11120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 12120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 13120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 14120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 15120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 16120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 17120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 18120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 19120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 20120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 21120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 22120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 23120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 24120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 25120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 26120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 27120 Milligan Pl South Orange Village Twp., NJ - Image 28
Presented By: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
  • MLS# 3998004
  • 11/14/2025
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 14
  • Baths • 4

Home Details

Rare Investment Opportunity - Legal Boarding House + Victorian Gem in Prime South Orange! Own two adjacent, income-generating properties. 120 & 122 Milligan Place offered together as a turnkey rental portfolio just steps from Seton Hall University and NYC Trains. Combined income is approx: $23,500/month. 120 Milligan (MLS #3979738) is a rare, legal boarding house, fully occupied, offering exceptional rental flexibility to individuals or groups. The first floor includes a 4-bedroom, 1 bath unit with a spacious kitchen, dining are, and private entrance. There is also a separate studio apartment with kitchenette, full bath, and its own entrance. The second and third floors contain 9 individually rental rooms with shared baths and common areas. Shared laundry and off-street parking add to the appeal.122 Milligan Place (GSMLS #3998001) is a beautifully maintained 11-bedroom, 3-bath Victorian with a wraparound porch, large yard, in-house laundry, and recent capital improvements. Current lease is $9,500/month. Both properties are ideally located near Seton Hall, and NYC Transport ensuring consistent demand from a wide variety of tenants. A rare, high-yield opportunity in one of NJ's strongest rental markets!
Presented By: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

Interior Features for 120 Milligan Pl

Bedrooms

Total Bedrooms14
Unit 1 Beds Total4
Unit 2 Beds Total1
Unit 3 Beds Total9

Bathrooms

Half Baths0
Unit 1 Baths Total1.0
Unit 2 Baths Total1.0
Unit 3 Baths Total2.0

Other Interior Features

Unit 1 Sq Ft0
Unit 2 Sq Ft0
Unit 3 Sq Ft0
Unit 1 Levels1
Unit 2 Levels1
Unit 3 Levels2
UnitType1TotalRent4120
UnitType2TotalRent1458
UnitType3TotalRent8417
Unit 3 Fireplaces0
Unit 3 Handicap ModifiedNo
Unit 2 Handicap ModifiedNo
Unit 2 Fireplaces
Unit 1 Fireplaces
Unit 1 Handicap ModifiedNo
Unit 1 Appl/EquipCarbMDet, CeilFan, CookGas, Dishwshr, KitExhFn, Refrig, SmokeDet, OvnWGas
Unit 2 Appl/EquipCarbon Monoxide Detector, Smoke Detector
Unit 3 Appl/EquipCarbon Monoxide Detector, Smoke Detector
BasementUnfinished, Walkout
Fuel TypeGas-Natural
Interior AmenitiesCarbon Monoxide Detector, Fire Extinguisher, Smoke Detector

Other Rooms

Unit 2 Rooms2
Unit 1 Rooms6
Unit 3 Rooms9
Unit 3 Room DescriptionBedrooms
Unit 1 Room DescriptionBedrooms, Eat-In Kitchen, Living/Dining Room
Unit 2 Room DescriptionBedrooms, Kitchen

General for 120 Milligan Pl

Architectural Style3-Three Story
CoolingWindow A/C(s)
CountyEssex
DirectionsProspect to Milligan
DriveAdditional Parking, Blacktop, Driveway-Shared
EasementUnknown
Full Baths4
Gross Income13995
HeatingBaseboard - Hotwater
High SchoolCOLUMBIA
Net Operating Income9800
Number Of Units Total3
Open Parking Spaces9
Operating Expense4194
PossessionAT CLOSE
RoofAsphalt Shingle
SewerPublic Sewer
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive
Tax Annual Amount21730
Tax Assessed Value866100
Tax Lot6
Tax Year2024
Total Rooms17
Town #1619
TownshipSouth Orange Village Twp.
UtilitiesElectric, Gas-Natural
Year Built1854

Exterior for 120 Milligan Pl

Exterior DescriptionVinyl Siding
Lot Dimensions.172 AC
Lot Size Acres0.17
Water SourcePublic Water

Additional Details

Price History

Schools

High School Columbia High School
Elementary School N/A
Middle School N/A

Tina Torres

Broker/Owner
Price $1,295,000
MLS#3998004
List Date 11/14/2025
Property Type Multi-Family
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 120 Milligan Pl

Get Pre-approved