Property

West Orange Twp., NJ 07052 21 Sheffield Ter

21 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 121 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 221 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 3
45 more
21 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 421 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 521 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 621 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 721 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 821 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 921 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 1021 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 1121 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 1221 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 1321 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 1421 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 1521 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 1621 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 1721 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 1821 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 1921 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 2021 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 2121 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 2221 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 2321 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 2421 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 2521 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 2621 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 2721 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 2821 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 2921 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 3021 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 3121 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 3221 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 3321 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 3421 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 3521 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 3621 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 3721 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 3821 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 3921 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 4021 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 4121 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 4221 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 4321 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 4421 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 4521 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 4621 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 4721 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 4821 Sheffield Ter West Orange Twp., NJ - Image 49
Presented By: COMPASS NEW JERSEY, LLC
  • MLS# 4033768
  • 06/10/2026
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 4
  • Baths • 3
  • Garage • 1

Home Details

THIS ONE-OF-A-KIND MIDCENTURY MODERN HOME IS UNLIKE ANYTHING YOU'LL FIND IN THE SOUGHT-AFTER GREGORY SECTION! Nestled within a private backyard that feels like a resort, enjoy the heated pool, bluestone terraces, a pergola-covered patio, built-in hot tub, treehouse, basketball, & even a tetherball court...a spectacular secluded oasis! As you step inside, the midcentury modern bones are intact and equally breathtaking. The main level flows from an expansive living room - with wood-beamed ceilings, period fireplace - through to a large dining area and chef's kitchen with Viking stove, pantry storage, and built-in breakfast table. In true MCM form, windows create a seamless indoor-outdoor flow, which is highlighted by views to the adjacent den with its floor-to-cathedral ceiling windows that frame every season beautifully. The primary suite is its own sanctuary: generous bedroom, flex room ideal for WFH or yoga, walk-in closet, and a spa-worthy en-suite bath. Two spacious bedrooms share this level, each with custom built-ins, as well as an updated full bathroom. A stunning, floating staircase leads to the lower level where you'll find a fourth bedroom, full bath, separate entrance, and a massive rec room with full wet bar - the perfect space to gather. A private retreat that is minutes from everything: NYC commuting options, Rock Spring Golf Course, South Mountain Reservation, & Turtle Back Zoo. Homes this unique are a rare find - don't miss it!
Presented By: COMPASS NEW JERSEY, LLC

Interior Features for 21 Sheffield Ter

Bedrooms

RoomBed4LevelGround
RoomBed3LevelFirst
RoomBed2LevelFirst
RoomBed1LevelFirst
RoomBed1Features1st Floor, Full Bath, Other Room, Walk-In Closet
Total Bedrooms4

Bathrooms

Master Bath FeaturesJetted Tub, Stall Shower
Half Baths

Kitchen

Kitchen FeaturesEat-In Kitchen, Galley Type
Kitchen LevelFirst

Other Interior Features

BasementFinished, Walkout
Fireplace FeaturesLiving Room
FlooringStone, Tile, Wood
Fuel TypeGas-Natural
In-Law SuiteYes
Interior AmenitiesBarWet, CeilBeam, Blinds, CeilCath, CeilHigh, JacuzTyp, Skylight, SmokeDet, StallTub, Steam, TrckLght, WlkInCls
Total Fireplaces1

Other Rooms

RoomDiningFeaturesLiving/Dining Combo
RoomBed4LevelGround
RoomBed3LevelFirst
RoomBed2LevelFirst
RoomBed1LevelFirst
RoomBed1Features1st Floor, Full Bath, Other Room, Walk-In Closet
Level 1 Rooms3Bedroom, BathMain, BathOthr, Den, DiningRm, Kitchen, Laundry, LivDinRm, MudRoom, OutEntrn, Walkout
Ground Level Rooms1Bedroom, BathOthr, Vestibul, RecRoom, Storage, Utility, Walkout
Den LevelGround
Dining Room LevelFirst
Family Room LevelFirst
Kitchen FeaturesEat-In Kitchen, Galley Type
Kitchen LevelFirst
Living Room LevelFirst

General for 21 Sheffield Ter

AppliancesDishwasher, Dryer, Kitchen Exhaust Fan, Range/Oven-Gas, Refrigerator, Washer
Architectural StyleSee Remarks
Community LivingNo
Cooling3 Units, Central Air
CountyEssex
DirectionsGregory Ave to Winding Way to Sheffield-continue past the lower section of Sheffield up Winding Way to find the private driveway at 21 Sheffield Terr
DriveDriveway-Exclusive
EasementUnknown
Elementary SchoolGREGORY
Full Baths3
GarageCarport-Attached
Garage Spaces2
Heating3 Units, Forced Hot Air
High SchoolW ORANGE
Middle/Junior High SchoolROOSEVELT
Open Parking Spaces2
OwnershipFee Simple
Pool FeaturesHeated, In-Ground Pool
Possessionat closing
Primary StyleSee Remarks
RoofFlat
ServicesCable TV Available, Fiber Optic Available, Garbage Included
SewerPublic Sewer, Sewer Charge Extra
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive
Sub Property TypeSingle Family
Subdivision NameGregory
Tax Annual Amount27013
Tax Assessed Value1028300
Tax Lot5
Tax Year2025
Total Rooms11
Town #1622
TownshipWest Orange Twp.
UtilitiesElectric, Gas-Natural
Water HeaterGas
Year Built1956

Exterior for 21 Sheffield Ter

Exterior AmenitiesHotTub, OpenPrch, Patio, Pergola, Storage, Sprinklr, FencWood
Exterior DescriptionCinder Block, Vertical Siding, Wood
Lot Dimensions150X228
Lot FeaturesCul-De-Sac, Wooded Lot
Lot Size Acres0.79
PoolYes
Water SourcePublic Water

Additional Details

Price History

Schools

Elementary School Gregory Elementary School
Middle School Roosevelt Middle School
High School W Orange High School

Brian Lee

Associate
Price $1,299,000
MLS#4033768
List Date 06/10/2026
Property Type Single Family
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 21 Sheffield Ter

Get Pre-approved